Old Sugar Distillery

931 E Main St #8, Madison, WI 53703, USA

Address:	931 E Main St #8, Madison, WI 53703, USA
Phone:	+1 608-260-0812
Site:	oldsugardistillery.com
Rating:	4.6
Working:	Closed Closed Closed 4–11PM 4–11PM 12–11PM Closed

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 37

Liam Sahm

Horrible service! I dont normally post reviews. Especially negative ones because ya never know if someone may be just having a bad day or maybe something happened that may be impacting them that day but this issue was from almost all that worked there. We were looking for a place we havent been to yet, a unique pace for a nice drink. When we walked In i mentioned we were first timers there and that we would like a recommendation based on what I explained we were kinda looking for. The response was drab and seemed like we were annoying him. There were no little pleasantries, welcome. We got our drinks and the longer we sat there the more awkward it was. Even the silent communication between the staff were unpleasant. Im sorry to the owners/management/employees and regulars that I posted this. I am just hoping that this post will be noticed and worked on as I have high hopes for businesses to do well and thrive or at least do well. The drink was excellent!!

Michael Dennison

We had our wedding reception at Old Sugar Distillery in August 2015. It was a fantastic venue for our group. Nathan and the staff were incredibly helpful in the time leading up to the big day and worked with us early that morning so that we could set up the space to our specifications. There was enough room to set up a buffet style meal, and there is a dedicated bar in the warehouse event space. We were able to hook up our own music and there was plenty of picnic table seating that they had just added. The night went off without a hitch. Our guests were blown away by the space and the quality of the cocktails. It was an amazing night that we will never forget. Other than the wedding we love having a relaxing cocktail on the weekends and stocking up on bottles of Gringo around the holidays.

Eric Kindschi

Great service and excellent drinks served in a decent space with no food. The spirits are tasty, the cocktails delicious. The gringo seems to be the gateway drink here, with other favorites being added infrequently. The root beer is tasty, as are both varieties of chai toddy (my friends agree the drink is better with ouzo than honey liqueur). This is a wonderful place to visit early in the evening. Conversation becomes difficult as the room fills; nigh impossible around the large, round table near the door.

A Private User

Excellent! I had a Honey Cup and a friend had The Standard, both pronounced highly drinkable. We went on a Friday evening, after dinner, and it was steady enough to be fun, but I was able to get drinks right away. The bartenders were professional and kind. We ended up sitting outside and had a great view of the capitol building above the old factories. Its a pretty cool location, I could see other business taking advantage of this clean, open, urban landscape.

Hans Christenson

This is definitely the place to go to if you are looking for a cool location with great drinks, but dont expect a huge variety in the menu and dont come here hungry as there isnt any food to speak of. However, if you want a good cocktail or a great gift (since they sell a variety of bottles and gift sets) Id highly recommend it. There is also a nice selection of tables outside during the summer.

Daniel Fischer

I went here with 3 other people with a livingsocial deal. First off that deal was very awesome! We each had about 3 tastings, 2 cocktails and split a meat and cheese plate. The sorghum whiskey was the best! That has to be in my top two whiskeys of all time. The staff was wonderful and very helpful. The bar was clean and spacious. This is truly a gem in the heart of Madison.

Michael Winger

Favorite place in Madison to get cocktails. The honey liquor is a whopping 80 proof and is amazing. Highly recommend the Honey Cap and the Gringo. Very reasonably priced. They have some food now including Banzo hummus and some cheese/meat boards which is a great addition. My only complaint is that theyre only open until 10PM.

Colin Bowden

Looks great and drinks seem nice, but service needs improvement. I asked nicely, held my hands up, tried to get the attention of the two tenders to no avail. This is the second time Ive had this happen and only at this establishment does this happen.

Sara Wright

This place is clean and well lit, a helpful staff, and a vibe that reminded me of Asheville. Highly recommended on a chilly night to warm up with a whiskey or honey liqueur. Also: They have a pretty nice bike rack, which can be hard to come by.

Kersten Bartelt

The drinks were great, the location is cool, decorated well. We went on a Saturday so it was pretty busy, took a whIle to get acknowledged even sitting at the bar and we didnt get checked on much. I would go back maybe on a less busy night.

Jon Nichols II

Lovely liquor batch produced by hipsters. It is delicious. Great place to go with friends and have a couple drinks. Remember, this is a distillery first, not a bar... Hours are limited, and the drink menu isnt extensive.

Michael Beeler

Good service in a cool setting with really unique cocktails. Their flights are a good value, and they have some appetizers as well. I am looking forward to seeing their new releases in the future!

Matt Filteau

This is a great place to casually drink really good craft cocktails. I would recommend getting the grappa when it is in season, it tends to go fast.

Zach Heise

Excellent cocktails with just the right amount of bite to them. Indoor and outdoor seating. Wish they didnt use so much ice in the drinks though.

Vincent Hsu

Ive been coming to this place for almost 5 years now. The drinks here has never disappointed me and service has been excellent.

Paul M

Great atmosphere, seems very upscale. Average prices. Tried the honey cap. Very sweet and strong honey flavor

Robert Phetteplace

I love every single drink they serve here and their whiskey is my go to brand for at home!

Zach Pace

Very knowledgeable bar staff; always pleasantly full on weekends; try the flights!