The Nutty Irishman of Farmingdale

Address:	323 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA
Phone:	+1 516-293-9700
Site:	thenuttyirishman.com
Rating:	3.4
Working:	12PM–4AM 12PM–4AM 12PM–4AM 12PM–4AM 12PM–4AM 12PM–4AM 10:30AM–4AM

Location

+−

Leaflet

Photos 100

Reviews 38

Barbara Sacchi

If your looking for a great place to have a party this is the place!! I had my nephews 40th birthday party this past weekend and people are still talking about it. We had the entire back room and were over 90 people. There was plenty of room for everyone. It was a very causal party (bar atmosphere). From the start of planning the party with Katharine, she made the whole process so easy to plan. Very helpful and her suggestions worked really well. When I arrived at the party, Katharine had made sure every decoration and table was set up beautifully. The perfect party planner and very attentive. I couldnt have done it any better myself. The catering menu had plenty of food options to choose from. Everyone raved about the food, especially the penne vodka, chicken francaise and what there known for, Nutty Irishman barbque steak. The 2 bartenders Anthony and Kristina were great. Very attentive and personable. They handled the party with such ease. As far as the servers, we had Joanne, Eileen and Katharine. There work was incredible. Always had a smile, very personable, very attentive and making sure everyone had food including making sure the couple of lil ones we had got there chicken tenders delivered to them personally. Ive had many parties before ie catering halls and restaurants but this one was by far the easiest one yet. The staff at the nutty irishman are truly exceptional!!

jen bonilla

St. Patricks day gave me a distaste for this place. It was 9 of us in total. After waiting on line we paid 10 dollars each just to go into an over crowded ,sardine packed , hot steamy environment. We left in 5 minutes when we couldnt even get to the bar because it was insanely over packed and bartenders overwhelmed. I asked for a refund and they said no. It must be nice to just take peoples money when they know they over exceeded their limit of people , isnt there a town ordinance? should we call a Fire Marshall? god-forbid something happens such as a fire , how do you plan to evacuate? , where are your security? Its unsafe and illegal! my friends and i, will not be going there ever, nor suggesting it to anyone.

Yuliya Vaden

this could be your favorite place or not, depending on your crowd. I look like a white crow going there semi dressed up. People roll in there in dirty jeans and pajamas and uggs so it is literally nutty in there. Unless its your clang. You may feel like an overdressed person at Walmart. Nevertheless dj plays modern dancing music and remixes it well. The dj shifts with a band by hours. 11pm dance music. By 12 its a rock band.

Samantha Sigelakis-Minski

Extremely cheap beer with crazy good happy hour specials, but dont expect anything crazy. Decent selection, but it is never that cold. They often give out free samples of their apps, which are subpar but again super cheap. This is a dive bar at its best, so you know what you are getting into. One of the few affordable places still on the strip, and you never get hassled if you linger.

simon bolin

Went in the later afternoon for a quick drink, the bartender was excellent! I told him what I typically drink and he got close with the first try and dead on with the second. Had the pretzel and o-rings too, both were awesome. Looking forward to heading back here to watch a game.

Richard Kerr

I had a great time tonight in farmingdale. I think the street fair in front of the nutty Irishman is a fantastic idea. Was with my daughter and the grandkids saw so old faces from the past. The farmingdale community is like no other. 5 stars easy

Gary Gordon

Yes, I did love it ! Food, drink and atmosphere on Country Tuesdays is everything I could ask for. The dance floor, DJs and sound system all combined to make the night something to remember. The LIVE music was very good that night also.

George Kraus

Went to hear some 70s music. Apps were good. Band played until 10:00 then stopped. Figured it was a break. After 1 hour asked staff if the band was going back on and was told a new band was going on at 11:30. Would have been nice to know.

Mark Cansino

Great selection of beers. Seasonal drink options available. By day the space is moderate in size. On weekends the space opens up to triple in size with 2 additional bars, live music, DJ, dance floor and outside patio in the back.

Deli Time

Total dump. Lame bartenders who cant count money, goofy 1980s interior, and zero crowd. The middle of summer, and they didnt even have the air conditioning on! Guess they were trying to keep down the electric bill.

nick Bourgade

The crowd is way too young and the drinks taste different every time. I gave it 3 stars instead of less because they always forget to charge me for some of my drinks

Derek Donnelly

The staff are rude and unreasonable. A 52 year old person cannot enter if they forgot thier drivers license but has other government issued ID. Your assholes.

Dakota Diamond Author

I have been here a dozen times at least. I love their chicken wings and of course their drinks! The love of all love, is the loved of being loved!

Timothy Shavuo

My wife and I went here to do a paint night. The bartenders were friendly. The paint instructions were nice. It was definitely a good experience.

Mike Nello

We planned on bar hopping in Farmingdale but the great music, food, and drinks kept us at The Nutty Irishman all night.

Deborah Tannenbaum

Excellent burger cooked perfectly meat tender and not dried out nor dripping with grease great nachos!

Dave Nap

I freaking love this place! The girl that bartends on Sundays is very nice and has a cute smile

Rob Carroll

Nice small bar to hang out and have a few drinks. Friendly and helpful staff