Mouse Trap Cafe Wine and Cheese Bar, Full Bar

Address:	203 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, USA
Phone:	+1 631-691-6600
Site:	mousetrapcafe.com
Rating:	4.6
Working:	Closed 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM 11:30AM–12AM Closed

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 28

danmcbabe

I came on here to write a review realizing most of the people who have written reviews, havent even visited the establishment yet. First of all, I would like to state that my first experience truly wasnt bad. Now, to say the least, my second experience was horrible. We decided to break away from our usual places for once. We decided to try new wine, cheese and meats. We got the board and realized the cheese wasnt the cheese we ordered and there was clothing fuzz all over it. After we explained the issue, the waiter wasnt thrilled to send it back but did it as respect for us. This must not of gone over so well with whoever made it because it was almost a spiteful nature to give us the correct cheese but remove most of the garnishes. Half the grapes and nuts were missing... It was as if they knocked everything off to mock us. I thought it was such an incredible place and I still gave an excellent tip but with that being said I dont believe this is a place to visit. Id rather be honest to the people who may be deciding. Im shocked and I am sorry I had to leave this because I had high high hopes as well for this place.

Steve Marcus

We were there on JayCees opening night. She was amazing, as always. Because we dont drink and I dont eat cheese, we found the menu lacking. I had a turkey sandwich without cheese and my wife Mimi has a panini that she says was the best she ever had. The cafe is absolutely classy and amazing, but I think you need more of a food menu. We would love to bring our friends for dinner and a show, but the menu is not sufficient. How about some really classy salads? With grilled chicken? More choices is what I suggest. We will always come here to see JayCee. Mimi & Steve

TORRIE CREAMER

A good selection of wine from all over. A fair choice of cheese and cured meat, the staff could not be friendlier very efficient and helpful, this place out stands most of local attractions in Amityville regarding service and friendliness of staff. Good Job ! Will go again every time I visit Amityville.

Kristen Watts

I put 3 stars because I didnt get to eat here. Google said it opened at 11:30 today. the mouse trap website says 12. showed up at 12:30, place was totally closed, no signs of life, no hours posted. was really looking forward to it. will edit my review once I actually eat here.

John Becker

Excellent setup. Spacious stage for live music. Courteous and helpful servers. Good atmosphere. Varied seating so could sit on a couch, sit at the bar, sit at high bar tables or sit at low tables. Adult music was playing. Very much enjoyed.

Renata Comenale Souza

The place is beautiful and the food is amazing!!! Many different options and so far all delicious!! Great chef!! Prices are good, and theres live band playing classic rock on weekends. Staff is super nice. I live this place!

Christine Corrado

Wishing you all the best at The Mouse Trap Cafe. We cant wait to come see it when we are up for a visit. Much luck and success always from all of us in Saint Augustine, FL at LipWallys Twisted Radio Show :)

Diane Ortiz

Anxiously awaiting the grand opening. Would love to see "Milagro", the Santana tribute band here on Long Island play at the opening. They would rock the house!!

Mouse Trap Cafe Wine bar

The Mouse Trap will be opening soon we are currently waiting on Suffolk County to issue our clearance we will notify everyone by Social Media. Thank you.

Harrison Kyle Jones

Finally, a place with class dedicated to the classical (Rock) arts. Wine, beer, libations and music aplenty!!!

Anthony Piccirillo

Was a great place. Seems to me that it is out of business. Sorry things didnt work out owners were very nice.

Alicia Figueras

Bendicion with your new venture...

Jim Carleton

Great ambiance, friendly hosts and patrons. Best spot for live music. Cozy bar. Light food, tapas.

caryn kantor

This is the type of place we need out here-unique, and theres food and live music!

My Mad House TV

Great place coming soon to the village of Amityville with incredible entertainment